Why Secondary Schools Struggle to Teach Foundational Literacy

Discover why secondary students struggle with foundational reading and how new platforms like EdenFiftyOne aim to identify and fix exact literacy gaps.

Friday, April 10, 2026

Key Takeaways

  • About one in three secondary students fails to meet expected literacy benchmarks. This creates a mismatch when these students receive advanced reading assignments.
  • The UK's statutory Phonics Screening Check increased Year 1 reading scores from 58% to 80%. However, these gains did not lead to better outcomes by Year 5.
  • Secondary educators are trained in specific subjects rather than foundational reading mechanics. They are often unequipped to teach students who struggle with reading.
  • Platforms like [EdenFiftyOne](https://edenfiftyone.com/) map discrete English skills to show teachers student knowledge gaps before high-stakes exams.

Former English teacher Tom Reynolds launched EdenFiftyOne, an educational platform that divides secondary English instruction into 51 foundational skills. The tool addresses a problem where middle and high school students must analyze advanced literature without mastering basic reading and writing.

What Happened

Secondary teachers often teach complex texts to students who lack basic literacy. Reynolds, who was diagnosed with dyslexia at age 21, describes this mismatch as forcing teachers to "ice cakes that aren't baked properly."

To fix this, Reynolds mapped literacy demands across various exam boards. His platform identifies 51 core skills in reading, writing, speaking, and listening. By tracking students against each skill on a color-coded dashboard, the platform shows teachers exact knowledge gaps before students take high-stakes exams.

The Bigger Picture

The assumption that students enter secondary school with secure literacy skills is flawed. Around one in three secondary students fails to meet expected literacy benchmarks, according to a report by EducationHQ.

This creates friction in the classroom. Secondary educators are trained to teach content, not foundational reading mechanics, leaving them ill-equipped to support struggling readers, as detailed by SAGE Publications. In Wales, inspections show that inconsistent leadership and uneven teaching hinder student progress.

Early interventions often fail to produce long-term comprehension. The UK’s statutory Phonics Screening Check improved Year 1 reading scores from 58% to 80% over a decade, but research from the Education Policy Institute shows this did not lead to improvements in Year 5 reading, according to the Raedan Institute.

Educators are divided on the path forward. Advocates for structured literacy argue that breaking language into discrete skills helps students who struggle to decode text, according to Kids Up Reading Tutors. Conversely, researcher Carl Hendrick argues that reading comprehension is not a procedural skill that can be isolated. He notes that students who fail to grasp a text usually lack the necessary vocabulary and background knowledge to understand it.

Schools often overload classrooms with disconnected software instead of using a unified system to track student progress, as we previously reported.

What This Means for Families

When a secondary student struggles with English, parents should not assume the issue is a failure to understand a specific assignment. Often, the student misses a foundational skill—like sentence construction or specific vocabulary—that was glossed over in earlier grades.

Because the curriculum continues regardless of these gaps, generalized classroom instruction is rarely enough. Successful secondary programs use multi-tiered systems of support (MTSS) alongside core classes to teach advanced decoding and vocabulary, according to Voyager Sopris Learning.

What You Can Do

  • Ask your child's English teacher how they identify and measure foundational literacy gaps before assigning grades on complex essays.
  • Request explicit, data-driven reading interventions if your child is struggling.
  • Build your child's background knowledge and broad vocabulary at home through documentaries, museums, and varied reading.
Share: